Pollo Tropical Creamy Curry Mustard Sauce {Copycat Recipe}

Pollo Tropical Creamy Curry Mustard Sauce {Copycat Recipe} is a delicious dipping sauce for Fried Yucca and fantastic in egg salad.

Pollo Tropical Creamy Curry Mustard Sauce

In South Florida, there is a chain restaurant called Pollo Tropical, not to be confused with Pollo Loco, in California.  The restaurants are not related, but both use fresh ingredients and cook their chicken, right there in the open.  Pollo Tropical is considered a “Caribbean” Fast Food restaurant.  Hmmmm…..

My favorite thing on the menu is the Yucca Fries with Curry Mustard Sauce.  Oh my gosh, the sauce is so incredible.  The restaurant has a condiment bar in the middle of it and patrons are free to take what they want.  Although they have a Drive-Thru, I always opted to go inside the restaurant to order.  Why?  Because then I can load up on the delicious Curry Mustard Sauce.

Cast of Ingredients for Pollo Tropical Creamy Curry Mustard Sauce

When we moved back to Los Angeles, I made a special trip to Pollo Tropical, just so I could grab some to-go Curry Mustard Sauce.  We drove across the Country in our RV, so I froze containers of the sauce.

When I ran out, well, it just wasn’t pretty.  I tried to make the Sauce myself and came very close.  After searching on line, I found a recipe that claimed to be a copycat of my beloved Pollo Tropical Creamy Curry Mustard Sauce.  I was thrilled, as I had guessed the ingredients, but not the exact measurements.  My Sauce, my sauce!!!!!!  Come to me.

Not only is this Pollo Tropical Creamy Curry Mustard Sauce terrific on my Air Fryer Yucca Fries, it makes a delicious dipping Sauce for my Air Fryer Pub Style Corned Beef Egg Rolls and is fantastic poured over my Pressure Cooker Spanish Tortilla {Cuban Egg Frittata}.

Mix up all Ingredients

Add all the ingredient to a bowl.  This only makes about 4 ounces, so you might want to double the recipe, so you can use it on all kinds of things. As a sandwich spread, dipping sauce, over a grilled steak, the possibilities are endless.  It’s ridiculous how only a few simple ingredients tastes so wonderful as a sauce.

Whisk Ingredients until Completely Smooth

Use a Whisk and combine the ingredients until the Sauce is very smooth.  Put some muscle into this, to make sure all ingredients are well combined.  Or,

Add all Ingredients to Vitamix and Process until Smooth

you can do what I do and pull out my trusty Vitamix and give it a quick whirl.  In just a couple of seconds, you will have the most delicious copycat version of the Pollo Tropical Creamy Curry Mustard Sauce. 

Pollo Tropical Creamy Curry Mustard Sauce

It is a fabulous dipping sauce for my Air Fryer Yucca Fries.  Use this Sauce, instead of plain mayonnaise when making an Egg Salad Sandwich.

Kitchen Equipment and Essentials

• Amco Advanced Performance 18/10 Stainless Steel Measuring Spoons
• Rösle Stainless Steel Flat Whisk– a MUST have, probably my most used utensil
• VitaMix 7500
• Ball 4 oz Mason Jars

Caring is sharing!  If you would like to support This Old Gal, please share this recipe on Social Media, so that I can continue to bring you more wonderful recipes!

Here is the handy printable recipe:

5 from 1 vote

Print

Pollo Tropical Creamy Curry Mustard Sauce {Copycat Recipe}

Prep Time

5 mins

 

Pollo Tropical Creamy Curry Mustard Sauce {Copycat Recipe} is a delicious dipping sauce for Fried Yucca and fantastic in egg salad.

Course: Condiment

Cuisine: Caribbean, Cuban

Servings: 4 oz

Author: This Old Gal

Ingredients

• 4 Tablespoons Mayonnaise Light or Regular
• 2 teaspoons Yellow Mustard
• 1 teaspoon Curry Powder
• 4 Tablespoons Fresh Water

Instructions

1. Place all ingredients into Vitamix or Blender and process until smooth.

Don’t forget to Pin It! – Pollo Tropical Creamy Curry Mustard Sauce

Pollo Tropical Creamy Curry Mustard Sauce {Copycat Recipe}