Creamy Instant Pot Baked Ziti with homemade red sauce and three types of cheese is a “dump and go” recipe made quickly in the pressure cooker.
Although my TOG Cooking Group did not know exactly the recipe being voted on, the majority of people said they prefer a homemade sauce, rather than a jarred pasta sauce.
Without overstating the obvious, any recipe with my Homemade Pasta Sauce is just going to be better, period.
While a lot of people opted for a dump recipe with jarred sauce, I was determined to satisfy both groups, so that everyone wins.
Homemade sauce usually includes sauteing some of the ingredients, like onions and garlic, right?
Busy people don’t always have time for this, even if it only takes five minutes.
What Size Pressure Cooker Do I Need for Instant Pot Baked Ziti?
- I used my Mini 3 Quart Instant Pot Pressure Cooker for this recipe.
- Double it for your 6 Quart Instant Pot or Pressure Cooker, if you like.
How to Cut Instant Pot Baked Ziti Recipe in Half.
- Use half of the ingredients.
With my Instant Pot Creamy Baked Ziti recipe, everyone definitely wins.
The red sauce in Instant Pot Creamy Baked Ziti shouldn’t be thick and heavy, like you get from most jarred sauces.
It should be a simple and lighter saucy sauce. 🙂 The sauce is homemade and very saucy.
There is no sauteing at all! Yes, that is an onion.
Not only is there no sautéing of the onion, there is no chopping of it either!
While thinking about how to satisfy both groups of equally wonderful people, I remembered a trick I had seen on TV.
I love to watch cooking shows and shows about interesting and delicious food found at restaurants around the globe.
There is a show where the host travels the US and tastes all the best recipes.
When I have a little time (which is not often anymore), I watch the chef cook and then listen very carefully how the taste of the food is described and then sometimes plot to make something similar.
They never give you the full recipe, so this keeps me on my toes!
Anyway, peel the darn onion and then cut it in half.
That’s all you gotta do! Toss it right into the pot.
As this is a quick dump and cook recipe, I’m taking shortcuts from my usual whole peeled tomatoes, etc.
But, this is important. For optimal results, use good canned tomatoes.
Check the label and if it says “Imported from Italy,” you are good to go.
I’ve opted to use Fresh Water, rather than Pressure Cooker Chicken Broth in this recipe.
Why you are thinking? Because I love a good vegetarian Baked Ziti.
Heavy cream has enough fat in it, so that it won’t break a part and curdle, so it is added in with the sauce, water and wine.
If you don’t have heavy cream in the fridge, but you have a can of evaporated milk in your pantry, you can use that instead.
Why use Wine in Instant Pot Baked Ziti Recipe?
- Wine adds a nice depth of flavor and adds richness.
- You will have an added robustness to the sauce.
- Dry red wine is generally the wine of choice for red sauces, however, some dishes might benefit better from a fruity wine.
- Chianti is very popular to use in Italian recipes.
- Chardonnay, Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot is what I usually use.
What are the Seasonings for Instant Pot Creamy Baked Ziti?
- Kosher Salt
- Freshly Ground Black Pepper
- Red Pepper Flakes
- Oregano – optional
- Basil – optional
- Italian Seasoning – optional
This is a super simple Ziti with a luscious tomato sauce, which does not need a lot of extra seasonings.
Maybe a pinch of Dried Thyme would be nice as well.
In my opinion, however, sometimes a simple sauce is really good.
The sauce hasn’t even cooked yet and already it is rich. My di Oro Living Silicone Spatulas Set is all I need for this job.
How do you lower the tomato acidity in Instant Pot Baked Ziti?
- Normally, I use a piece of carrot, shredded and finely minced.
- A teaspoon of sugar is probably the most used helper for this cause.
- In this Instant Pot Baked Ziti recipe, the butter is the one to do the job and get ‘er done!
- Butter also adds an extra layer of creaminess.
Here is where I get very particular.
What is the Best Pasta for Instant Pot Baked Ziti?
- De Cecco brand pasta holds up very well in pressure cookers. It is a good and quality pasta.
- There is less of a chance of the pasta breaking a part. Plus, it tastes great!
- Amazon usually has the best prices for a pack of 5, so make sure to check out their prices.
- I always say, use the best you can afford and that often times, brand does not make a difference.
For pasta, brand does make a difference, as does a good olive oil (but we are not using oil here).
When you open the lid, hopefully, the onion will float to the top.
But, it’s easy to find.
All you have to do is remove the onion.
All the taste, no chopping or chunks!
With the short cook time, expect the pasta not to be fully cooked.
The hot sauce, will continue to be absorbed by the pasta, as you add the cheese.
We always buy blocks of cheese and shred the cheese ourselves.
The pre-shredded cheese never seems as good and there is a starchy coating on it to keep it from sticking.
This Microplane Artisan Ribbon Grater is very easy to use and takes little effort.
What kind of Cheese is used for Instant Pot Baked Ziti?
- The number one answer is Mozzarella, of course.
- Parmesan Cheese is also used, but often times, just on top.
- Ricotta Cheese makes this vegetarian Baked Ziti dish really special.
How to add Cheese to Instant Pot Baked Ziti.
- Add a handful at a time and mix, until melted.
- Make sure to check that the cheese is mixing in with the pasta, as the cheese may accumulate to the sides and bottom of the pot.
I happen to love Ricotta with pasta and have a tendency to go heavy.
So, start with a little and work your way up.
If you would like to add in fresh parsley, do it in this step.
I did not add it in and instead garnished my Instant Pot Baked Ziti.
However, you might notice, that I reached for the cilantro, rather than the parsley and had to pick it out after taking photos.
Enjoy! I’d love to know how you like this dish.
If you get a chance, please snap a picture and tag me on instagram. I’m #thisoldgalcooks!
I love to see photos!
Kitchen Equipment and Essentials
- Instant Pot, Mealthy MultiPot or Pressure Cooker
- Instant Pot DUO Mini Plus 3 Quart Pressure Cooker
- J.A. Henckels Classic 8 inch Chef’s Knife
- Amco Advanced Performance 18/10 Stainless Steel Measuring Spoons
- Culina Stackable (Dry) Stainless Steel Measuring Cups
- Anchor Hocking Glass (Liquid) Measuring Cups
- di Oro Living Silicone Spatulas Set
- Alton Brown Salt Box
- Gravity Electric Salt and Pepper Grinder
- De Cecco Ziti Pasta
- Pureed Tomatoes
More Delicious Instant Pot Pasta Recipes to Make.
- Instant Pot Pressure Cooker Blue Cheese Broccoli Butternut Pasta
- Instant Pot Spaghetti Dinner
- Instant Pot Buffalo Chicken Macaroni and Cheese
- Instant Pot Butternut Squash Pasta
- Instant Pot Beef Stroganoff
Caring is sharing! If you would like to support This Old Gal, please share this recipe on Social Media, so that I can continue to bring you more wonderful recipes!
If you share a picture of something you make from our blog, tag it with #thisoldgalcooks so we can see it. We might feature it on Instagram! It makes my day when I see you’ve made one of our recipes!
Here is the handy printable recipe:
Instant Pot Creamy Baked ZitiPrint Pin Rate
- 28 ounces Pureed Tomatoes
- 1 cup Fresh Water
- 1/4 cup Dry Red Wine (or water or chicken broth)
- 1/2 cup Heavy Cream
- 1 small/medium Yellow/Brown Onion cut in half
- 3 Tablespoons Butter
- 3 cloves Fresh Garlic smashed
- 2 teaspoons Italian Seasoning Blend optional
- 2 teaspoons Kosher Salt
- 1/4 teaspoon Freshly Ground Black Pepper
- 1 Pinch Crushed Red Pepper Flakes
- 8 ounces Ziti Pasta Noodles
- 1/4 cup Asiago or Parmigiano-Reggiano cheese shredded
- 8 ounces Mozzarella Cheese shredded or sliced
- 1/2-1 cup Ricotta Cheese
- Peel and cut onion in half and add to cooking pot.
- Pour in pureed tomatoes, water, cream and wine (or water/broth).
- Add butter, Italian seasoning, garlic, salt, pepper and pepper flakes and mix through.
- Add Ziti noodles.
- Lock on lid and close pressure valve. Cook at high pressure for 2 minutes. When beep sounds, wait 3 minutes and then remove the rest of the pressure.
- Remove lid and retrieve the onion. Hit the sauté/browning button and slowly add in Mozzarella and Parmesan cheese and stir until melted.
- Mix in Ricotta cheese and add fresh parsley if desire.
Pin this Creamy Instant Pot Baked Ziti Recipe